How Personalized Benefits Can Help Small Businesses Compete
Some small business owners worry about their ability to offer the level of benefits needed to recruit and retain employees, but experts in the industry say focusing on “quality” offerings and more personalized benefits could help attract talent to their companies.
Here’s a look at some insight into employee benefits at small businesses, such as what benefits actually matter most to workers, how personalizing employee benefits can help small businesses with employee recruitment and retention, and alternatives to traditional plans.
Rethink How You Compete for Talent
It’s understandable for small business owners to be concerned their employee benefits will fall short, when their plan options are often limited compared to larger companies.
Nearly half of small business owners (49 percent) told a recent survey they worry their current benefits “aren’t going to cut it,” according to an article by EBN Editor Lee Hafner.
Further, 96 percent of small business owners concerned about hiring and retention believe it’s important to offer employees more variety in terms of health coverage, writes Hafner, citing a survey from professional employer organization Justworks and The Harris Poll.
While the concern is valid, in that large firms are often better positioned to offer a wider range of benefits options to employees, it isn’t always about more being better, says David Feinberg, SVP of risk and insurance at Justworks, in the EBN article by Hafner.
"Small businesses don't have to outspend large companies to compete,” he adds.
Rather than relinquish talent or overspend to keep employees, Feinberg advises small business owners to reframe their approach to the benefits selection process.
“If you’re a small-business owner, you actually have this superpower, which is the ability to get closer to your employees than potentially a large employer,” explains Feinberg.
What Workers Say About Benefits
Workers tend to rank health care coverage as their most valued benefit at a company. Yet it isn’t necessarily as clear-cut as that, a one-size-fits-all solution that attracts and retains employees.
In SHRM's 2026 Employee Benefits Survey, 88% of employers rated health-related benefits as very or extremely important to their workforce, while 82% gave the same rating to retirement and leave benefits.
Also high on the list were flexibility (66 percent), family-friendly benefits (65 percent) and professional development (64 percent), according to the SHRM 2026 Employee Benefits survey.
Employees have become discerning when it comes to offerings.
“In 2026, employees expect more than traditional coverage. They want personalized experiences, smarter tools, and benefits that support their whole lives,” explains Danielle Casey at Wex, a commerce platform that includes employee benefits.
In a Mercer survey, 41 percent of employees said their benefits don’t reflect their real needs, and nearly 70 percent told the poll that the ability to personalize benefits is important to them.
“The entrée model no longer fits. Employees need and want a buffet selection,” writes Joseph Coughlin in a Forbes article.
Understand the Challenges of Traditional Group Plans
Small businesses are often stuck with limited options, in part due to traditional plan requirements that are built around larger companies with more employees and larger budgets.
It can leave small business owners with fewer choices, says an article by EBN associate editor Paola Peralta.
“The type of health insurance that employers can offer has always been designed for very large employers with HR teams and brokers and benefits advisers,” says Marshall Darr, CEO of health-tech company StretchDollar, in the EBN post.
“Those companies have a whole infrastructure that these smaller employers just functionally do not have.”
Conventional health plans typically require employers to select and fund a group insurance policy and require them to manage costs and administration of the plan.
“For small businesses without dedicated HR teams, rising premiums, minimum participation requirements and the complexity of choosing benefits that meet employees’ varied needs can make these plans difficult to sustain,” Darr says in the article.
Consider an ICHRA or CHOICE Arrangement
An alternative model to a traditional employer plan is the Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement (ICHRA), also known as a CHOICE Arrangement, which offers benefits to small business owners.
Referred to as a ICHRA or Choice Arrangement, it’s an individual-market insurance where workers purchase their own qualifying individual coverage rather than enrolling in a health plan selected by their employer.
“Businesses of any size can offer an ICHRA, but small employers often prefer it because they may not have the resources or access to offer traditional group insurance,” explains a post by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce on its small business site CO.
With an ICHRA, small business owners choose a defined reimbursement amount for the employee, rather than those costs being tied directly to group premiums.
“Employers can set a benefits budget and let employees choose their own coverage, rather than navigating the complexities of selecting a group plan that balances prescription drug coverage, hospital networks and other needs,” writes EBN associate editor Peralta.
Depending on how the arrangement is structured and applicable eligibility requirements, an ICHRA may give employers additional flexibility in offering health benefits to different classes of employees.
“Adding part-time or seasonal workers to traditional group health plans is often cost-prohibitive,” says a blog by the payroll and HR company ADP.
This relatively new option, the post says, “allows employers to extend benefits to more types of employees, helping attract and retain talent in the process without overextending budgets.”
Also see 4 Ways to Improve Retention and Keep Your Employees Happy.
The trends, insights, and solutions you need to grow your business.
By signing up, you’re subscribing to our monthly email newsletter, The
Wire. You may unsubscribe at any time.
Your information stays safe with us. Learn more about our privacy
policy.