The Wire The Wire - Dedicated to making your business thrive Dedicated to making your business thrive

Inefficiently Effective: When Efficient Customer Service Isn't More Effective

Somewhere along the way, “How can we help you?” became “Please select from the following options.”

Businesses have good reasons to streamline. Labor costs money. Customers dislike waiting. And nobody starts the day hoping to fill out more paperwork. But efficiency has a blind spot: It measures how quickly something gets done more easily than how someone feels afterward.

For small and mid-sized businesses, that distinction matters. A shorter transaction might save money today. A customer who feels understood might keep coming back for years. Two real-life examples show why the fastest route through a transaction doesn’t always lead to the best destination.

When Self-Service Needed Some Help

Self-checkout promises a straightforward exchange: Customers handle the scanning, and retailers can serve more shoppers with fewer staffed registers. British supermarket chain Booths found reasons to reconsider.

In late 2023, the company began removing self-checkouts from most of its stores, favoring staffed lanes and a more personal shopping experience. In a subsequent interview with The Grocer, its managing director reported faster checkout service and reduced merchandise losses. Customer satisfaction also improved during a broader store investment program that emphasized hospitality and staff expertise.

That last detail matters: Removing machines wasn’t the only change. Still, the experience challenges the assumption that asking customers to do more automatically makes service more efficient.

For your business, consider where self-service creates extra work for the customer. Does your booking tool handle unusual requests? Can someone reach a person when the standard options don’t fit? A process that works beautifully until someone needs help deserves a closer look.

When a Return Became a Relationship

In 2022, Wisconsin resident Anna Brose contacted online pet retailer Chewy about returning unused prescription food after her dog, Gus, died.

Chewy refunded her purchase and suggested donating the food. Then flowers arrived, accompanied by a note from the employee who had helped her. Brose shared the experience publicly, drawing widespread attention to the company’s response.

A refund could have closed the transaction. The personal acknowledgment gave her something worth telling others about.

This single experience doesn’t establish a measurable increase in customer retention. It does illustrate how attention beyond the immediate request can earn goodwill that a routine confirmation email rarely inspires.

Small businesses don’t need a flower budget for every interaction. They need employees who can recognize when a customer’s situation calls for flexibility—and permission to respond thoughtfully.

Find the Minutes Worth Keeping

Neither example makes a case for slower service across the board. Customers still appreciate accurate orders, quick answers, and easy payments. The opportunity is to distinguish wasted time from worthwhile attention.

Before streamlining a customer interaction, ask:

  • Whose effort are we reducing? Saving staff time by making customers repeat information may simply move the burden.
  • What happens when the process fails? Make the route to human help easy to find.
  • What would an extra minute accomplish? An explanation or thoughtful question may prevent confusion and another call.
  • What are we measuring? Track repeat contacts, resolved problems, and customer feedback alongside transaction speed.

Use technology to handle routine work and give employees more room for judgment. Then let them exercise it. A customer who needs a receipt probably wants speed. A customer navigating a difficult decision may need a conversation.

The skill is knowing which moment you’re in. Your most efficient interaction might end quickly. Your most effective one might end with, “That’s why I keep coming back.”

Get TheWire Delivered to Your Inbox

The trends, insights, and solutions you need to grow your business.

By signing up, you’re subscribing to our monthly email newsletter, The Wire. You may unsubscribe at any time.
Your information stays safe with us. Learn more about our privacy policy.